Delish. get the recipe. ... Butterscotch is the new caramel. Recipe for Buttery Nipple pudding shots is a take on the slippery nipple combining year-round. Top off your favorite hard seltzer with a Fireball shot for some extra firepower. Last but not least, try this recipe which includes the ever-popular Fireball. Fireball French Toast. Recipes to Ignite the Nite. Fireball Oatmeal Cookie Drink. 1 part Fireball whisky; 1 part Irish cream; 2 parts coffee liqueur; 3 parts butterscotch schnapps; This recipe works well, as it has lots of creaminess and sweetness from the Irish cream plus coffee liqueur to temper the bite of Fireball. holidays. fall-winter. Irish Flag: Creme de menthe, Baileys, and brandy See recipe Pro … Half and Half: Baileys and Irish whiskey See recipe Pro tip: Add an extra kick by using Fireball in place of regular whiskey. a - z. z - a. Reset. party-occasions. Recommended. 3. Sort by. spring-summer. Ingredients: ½ oz Baileys; ½ oz Fireball; ½ oz Butterscotch Schnapps; Cinnamon Sugar; Fill your shaker halfway with ice and add the Baileys, Fireball, and … Filter by Tags. the-dragon-recommends. 5 Fireball Pumpkin Pie Shots. Fireball … If you're not convinced, all the more reason to see for yourself with these butterscotch apple cider shots. Or Afternoon.